The Debate On The French Revolution Essay - 1404 Words

The Debate on the French Revolution For the French Revolution, the historians are mainly entangled in the debate between two different interpretations. The Marxists recognize the French Revolution as the conflict between the old order (feudal system) and the modern society. On the other hand, the revisionists consider the French Revolution as essentially a political revolution, instead of a bourgeois revolution. From my perspective, the French Revolution is a combined consequence of both economic and political causes. Although revisionists have their valid arguments, I can’t agree with their ignorance of the social conflict, the complex economy France had, the resistance from the old order, and their stress on the liberal professionals being the leader of the revolution. However, I find the debate between the Marxists and the Revisionists is actually a discovering process for the French Revolution. The essential argument of the revisionists is that the French Revolution is not a bourgeois revolution. First, the revisionists think that in eighteenth century France, the economy had not yet transitioned into capitalism. Meanwhile, the revisionists suggest that before the French Revolution happened, the bourgeois was already sharing power with the aristocracy. Altogether they were the ruling elite of â€Å"notables†. Moreover, on the contrary to the Marxists, the revisionists minimize the role of the class struggle during the revolution. They view the French Revolution more as aShow MoreRelatedCauses Of The Haitian Revolution1215 Words   |  5 PagesThe Haitian Revolution was a monumental event and success for slaves in Saint Domingue which resulted in the end of slavery in this colony and the creation of the independent nation state of Haiti. This revolution occurred from 1791 to 1804 and was known as the most successful slave revolt in history. Slaves were forced to work for no pay and were seen and treated like property instead of human beings. There were many contributing factors of the Haitian Revolution including debates over slaveryRead MoreThe Vampyre By John Polidori Essay1355 Words   |  6 Pagesresponding to the times it was published in, times of immense social and technological change which Romantics such as Polidori tackled through their writings. The drivers of this disruptive change during Polidori’s time are two revolutions, that is, the Industrial and French -- both of which brought the Romantics much cause for lamentation or celebration. As such, a couple questions appear when considering these depictions, that is, what is Polidori doing with these depictions, is he lamenting theRead MoreThe French Revolution And The Revolution1221 Words   |  5 PagesWhen people think of the French Revolution, they immediately think of the country of France and how the Revolution affected it. What most people do not think about however, is how the Revolution affected other countries, specifically the country of England. England was affected positi vely and negatively by the Revolution in that there was an increase of political involvement, but there was a collapse in the economy due to war declared by France. The French Revolution created a battle of conflictingRead MoreNo One Factor Was Directly Responsible For The French Revolution1116 Words   |  5 PagesNo one factor was directly responsible for the French Revolution. Years of feudal oppression and fiscal mismanagement contributed to a French society that was ripe for revolt. The economical downturn may have been the kickstarter that began the revolution as the taxes rose higher and outrage at the crown heightened. The economy began to destabilise in the late 1700s, and the king decided to bring in financial advisers to look at the weakened French treasurey. Each adviser gave the king the sameRead MoreThe American Revolution Essay examples588 Words   |  3 PagesThe American Revolution was when the British colonies in America revolted against British rule for being taxed by people not even living on their land and gained independence by overthrowing British imperial rule under King George III. The French Revolution was a period of social and political upheaval in France, marking the decline of powerful monarchies and churches and the rise of democracy and nationalism. The French Revolution began less than two decades after the American Revolution. In many waysRead MoreThe French Revolution890 Words   |  4 Pagesas an â€Å"introduction to the French Revolution† by acquainting â€Å"the reader with the most important events, the prominent people, and the essential terms (xvi).â⠂¬  In her introduction, Neely discusses how the Revolution is still a hot-topic discussion amongst French-people and even how at the Bicentennial, there was still no definitive answers as to the â€Å"how† and â€Å"why† of the Revolution. Neely’s text is a great supportive source for a typical undergraduate French Revolution survey course. Neely utilizesRead MoreThe French Revolution : A Stepping Stone Into The Future878 Words   |  4 PagesThe French Revolution: A Stepping-Stone Into the Future The French Revolution of 1789 started simple because a group, the National Assembly of France, acting as representation for the people of France, attempted to help the struggling peasants by limiting of the monarchy’s power. The result was complete chaos: The end of French monarchy, the death of the king and queen, the Reign of Terror and Napoleon Bonaparte’s rise to power (French Revolution). These events all played a role in setting the nationRead MoreWays in Which the French Revolution had a Lasting Impact on France853 Words   |  4 Pages‘Libertà ©, à ©galità ©, fraternità ©Ã¢â‚¬â„¢: the motto that France uses to this day and first came about as a result of the French Revolution. This in itself shows that the revolution had a major impact on France. It played a significant role in changing France through, for example, the new definition of nationalism, the abolition of the monarchy and the abolition of feudalism. Whether these changes succeeded in modern ising France or resulted in something that was not any better than pre-revolutionary times isRead MoreFemale Dominance And Grisly Details Of The Haitian Revolution857 Words   |  4 PagesHistorians are increasingly interested in the male dominance and gruesome details of the Haitian Revolution. Unfortunately, the contributions of women in the Haitian Revolution are often overlooked by historians due to the horrors of the revolution. The few more works that do exist about women discuss their roles in slavery and their resistance in the Haitian Revolution. In recent years, some scholars are challenging the lack of women representation in the Haitian War of Independence. Scholars likeRead MoreThe French Revolution And The American Revolution1184 Words   |  5 PagesA revolution is not an event that comes around every few years. In fact, for an event to be considered a revolution that event must bring about significant political, social, ideological, religious or even technological change. Throughout history there have been some very noteworthy revolutions such as the Agricultural Revolution, the American Revolution, and the French Revolution. Of all the revolutions in history, it is perhaps the French Revolution that remains the most romanticized in the minds